no image

Is it possible to get rid of the traffic police — the global experience

Putin by his decree dismissed every fifth policeman in Russia. Maybe they are not needed at all?

On the first day of the new year came into effect the decree of the President of the Russian Federation on the reduction of the number of employees of the interior Ministry. Laid off employees of traffic police, which at the end of last year there were about 55 thousand. Now — on 10 thousand less. And mostly in Moscow and St. Petersburg.

There rose a murmur that to keep order on the roads becomes nobody, even the most complicated complexes commit violations will not replace real people. The camera will not stop a drunk, thief, posh on an opposite… now say “sealed room and do what you want”.

The most knowledgeable say that the traffic police as a separate structure altogether eliminate, transferring part of the functions of the Patrol, Regardie and purely civilian organizations.

But, first of all, as explains the Ministry of internal Affairs, was reduced in the first place incomplete, vacant posts of Desk officers. Obviously, one reason for this reduction is blatant corruption of the traffic police. Even the present head of the state traffic Inspectorate Chernikov in one of his first interviews after his appointment admitted that the traffic police are in the lead in the number of instituted criminal cases on the facts of corruption. How many episodes remains “behind the scenes”!

You do not need to wring their hands and bite your elbows. Such precedents in world practice full. Of course, there were unsuccessful experiments with Ukrainian traffic police DAI, after the abolition of which the accident rate increased by 20% for the half year, the service decided to return in an updated form called the DPS. But such a failure in the world — a rarity.

They have

In Georgia this reform was relatively easy and yielded great results. More recently, say the Georgians, the country had the highest level of corruption. The inspection was arranged for bribes to bribes to obtain. To cope with the scourge of the odious government of Mikhail Saakashvili helped method of shock therapy. First, on TV they started to show clips from Gai officers-bribe takers, taken with hidden cameras. Staged trials with long-term, and confiscation of property. Fired 70% of former police officers, 15 thousand people. Hired new employees and began to artificially raise the prestige of the profession, promoting the police as the keepers of the law.

If not for the inscription on the car, the Georgian police would be indistinguishable from the American. By the way, Georgian cops were obliged constantly to keep “chandelier” on patrol cars — to be seen from afar. Like beacons.If not for the inscription on the car, the Georgian police would be indistinguishable from the American. By the way, Georgian cops were obliged constantly to keep “chandelier” on patrol cars — to be seen from afar. Like beacons.

Now the inspection only examines the drivers, issues of law and registers cars. The order on the roads following the normal police. According to the General opinion (and I agree), are working properly. Of course, do not take any bribes, receiving a salary of 500-700 dollars, above the average level in the country, and valuing the service.

It is no secret that Saakashvili has taken the American police. There although there are traffic police, they are not isolated in a separate structure. Remember the movie. If the police did something wrong, the chief is threatening him that will translate into a patrol or even put a crossing guard at the intersection. Everything that makes the service a police officer, remains on the recording cameras installed in the vehicle and attached to clothing. A COP has the right to keep in his pocket only a small amount of money (up to $ 50). And to not be tempted to break the law, the average salary of a officer is around 40 thousand dollars a year. Plus early retirement, long holidays, free health insurance for the whole family and other benefits.

American police have been called the most strict. Only a madman can come to mind to offer a bribe to an officer of the highway patrol. And the last should be absolutely abnormal to extort.American police have been called the most strict. Only a madman can come to mind to offer a bribe to an officer of the highway patrol. And the last should be absolutely abnormal to extort.

How effective is this system? American cops are definitely not angels, otherwise, there would be no social movement copwatcher, that is, of citizens watching police and registered violations of the law. But on the roads in the United States relative order. Perhaps that is why the structure and principles of the American police copied in many countries.

In Lithuania the purse from the police may be no more than 38 euros with an average salary of 700 euros. Bribes put not only the police, but the drivers — givers, over the last 5 years these were about 4 thousand. Alternative real term is a large fine (so that not everyone is able to pay).

Kazakhstan road police be obliged to have to more than 8,000 tenge (less than 1500 roubles) and to annually submit a Declaration of income and expenses. The last concerns not only police themselves but also their families. Reduces the number of contacts between the police and drivers. For this most of the disorders tend to register with the help of complexes of fixing. And it’s interesting to upload files with the Registrar of the police, and car owners in the public file archive on the official site. And — most importantly — to refuse, at last, from “cane” system, increasing the responsibility of managers for the achievement of the bogus “positive” results. To inform the media about all cases of corruption.

In the Lao people’s democratic Republic prohibits the receipt of bribes directly recorded in the road traffic act, and the verification of documents is carried out from two police officers, controlling each other. In many countries encouraged when the police tell about the facts of receiving bribes colleagues. We call it squealing.

A little corny? Well, for example, in France for service in the traffic police attract mainly women because they are less prone to bribery.

Chinese policemen also value our work — especially against the background of strong competition. Unfair acting can lose service, and those who transgressed the law of liberty, and for a long time.Chinese policemen also value our work — especially against the background of strong competition. Unfair acting can lose service, and those who transgressed the law of liberty, and for a long time.

In China, the police play an online game in which destroy the graft. And also are regularly trained how to resist the temptation of the big, huge, gigantic bribes. However, the results of training clips else long prison terms for not able to resist the temptation. Really get even a sentence to death. According to official figures for corruption offences since the beginning of 2000s in China has shot 10 of thousands of officials. And revealing.

In 2011, the disciplinary Commission of the police of Sweden has examined the case road police stopped the owner of the restaurant for unfastened seat belt and a forgotten driver’s license. The perpetrator has offered to eliminate infringements and to treat police with salad. The officer left on duty, but was arrested.In 2011, the disciplinary Commission of the police of Sweden has examined the case road police stopped the owner of the restaurant for unfastened seat belt and a forgotten driver’s license. The perpetrator has offered to eliminate infringements and to treat police with salad. The officer left on duty, but was arrested.

And not so long ago, the Chinese officials for bribes to cut off the hands of — as well as in the United Arab Emirates and medieval Sweden. However, such was the case in our history, under Peter the great — as well as the branding, the whipping with a whip, followed the link, and even quartering. Today, of course, this is unacceptable, we live in a civilized and not a medieval society.

The carrot and the stick

So, all the bikes have been invented. To Chernikova on a relentless fight against corruption in the ranks of the state traffic Inspectorate declared all his predecessors — generals Nilov, Kiryanov, Fedorov, citing the same foreign experience. Video introduced, and the plant is not only for receiving but also the offer of a bribe. Wages rose. Though not as much as they could.

On average, police officers receive 36 000 rubles, and with the experience of over 15 years — 42 000 rubles. For large ranks and years of service you can get and more than 100 000 rubles. The leaders in terms of salaries reported Moscow and Irkutsk. This year the police salary should be raised, but not 1.5 times, as promised earlier, but only by a few percent, which is unlikely to offset inflation. That is, the average monthly salary is less than that policeman can obtain, for example, by releasing unpunished drunk driver. Without much risk: it helps Esprit de corps.

Is there a more corrupt police than us? If you believe the rumors — Yes, in African countries. This was written by Semenov in “TASS is authorized to declare”. And since the late 1970s, the situation has not changed. The picture shows the police of Somalia. Or those who pretend to be police officers.Is there a more corrupt police than us? If you believe the rumors — Yes, in African countries. This was written by Semenov in “TASS is authorized to declare”. And since the late 1970s, the situation has not changed. The picture shows the police of Somalia. Or those who pretend to be police officers.

We are able to pay the Russian police (not traffic cops) a big salary, if it will eradicate bribery and other crimes. To bring back all the old, revoked privileges. And the reduction in the number of police officers contributes to this. But to completely destroy the service it is very early. However, the interior Ministry from this project have refused.

However, if you are ready to get a lot of money — and be prepared to respond accordingly. About all cases of corruption should know the journalists. Not to wash dirty linen in public is possible only where there is no litter. And if it’s a private house and not public.

But first of all you should reduce the amount of paperwork, eliminating the “cane” system, to evaluate the effectiveness of the traffic police to reduce accidents (and should conduct independent monitoring organization). And the main thing — to drum into the consciousness and even the subconscious mind of the police that their main task is not to punish for violations but to prevent them.

Is it possible to get rid of the traffic police, the world opytnogo to get rid of the traffic police of world opitate: “Behind the wheel.Of the Russian Federation”

Залишити відповідь